Thursday, May 8, 2014

A Bad Review of Summers’ Love by Stu Summers

A few weeks back the romantic comedy Summers’ Love released as a Kindle eBook on Amazon and in print (available through Amazon.com, Barnes and Noble, and Goodreads.com). The author, Stu Summers, is a recluse. He lives on an island in the Caribbean, doesn’t have Internet or a cell phone, and apparently could care less what reviewers think of his book. His indie-publisher has a different take on this, since reviews can affect a book’s sales. Those of us here at Lighthouse Publishing of the Carolinas have been pushing for Stu to address the issue. 

This week, I finally received a response from Stu regarding comments and reviews from readers that we copied and pasted into a Word document, printed out, and mailed to him, along with these questions:

Q. Stu, it’s been a few weeks since your book Summers’ Love released. Any thoughts on how your book is doing?

A. First, I’d like to thank everyone who supported my book launch. I wish I could have been there to help but it’s probably best I remain down here helping in the medical clinic. Granted, I’m not much help, but any pair of extra hands is appreciated.



Speaking of appreciated, I really do appreciate the people who take the time to read my book. I take to heart the reader’s comments: both positive and negative. To be honest, I’m surprised Summers’ Love turned out as well as it did. Especially since this is my first real attempt at writing a novel. As readers know, my previous novels were ghost written. I’m not proud of that and make that clear in Summers’ Love.

I did the best I could, wrote from my heart, bled on the page, and followed my editor’s instructions. Well, tried to follow my editor’s instructions. Some like the story, some don’t. If your goal is to please everyone, you become a slave to all. So in general I’d say I’m pleased and will accept the criticism for what it is: helpful advice.

Q. There was some pushback among some readers suggesting your book wasn’t Christian. Did that surprise you?

A. Absolutely. Summers’ Love isn’t a Christian book. I’m not sure how a book can be Christian. It’s a book, not a person with a spirit and soul. I suppose given the other books my publisher releases, readers may have expected the book to maybe be a sermon or at least have a strong spiritual message. But that was never my intent. I’m just trying to tell a funny, romantic story about two people who are deceiving themselves and each other and happen to fall in love along the way. I think most people lead secret lives – even some Christians.

Q. Hate to bring this up, but there was a particular word in the story that offended certain readers. Care to address that?

A. You mean the word “breast”? Yes, I struggled with whether to include that word in the story. I mean, we all have them, but with guys it’s not as big a deal. Oops, that didn’t come out right. What I mean is, hardly anybody gets excited if a guy shows his breasts in public. Not that anybody shows any skin in Summers’ Love. Oh wow, this is so not coming out the way I’d planned. Let me try again.

Women refer to their upper body area as breast. Guys call this area our chest. So I used a word that I thought most women might use when describing the top half of the front portion of their body. And I do know that women will sometimes experience excitement in that region. I only mention that a few times in order to show emotion. My editor kept telling me to add more emotion. That might not have been exactly what she had in mind, though. Like I said, this was my first time writing a real novel.

But if I’m reading my publisher's letter correctly, the senior editor performed a mastectomy on my novel and removed five “breasts.” I suppose I should thank him. Hopefully this will make the book less offensive.

Q. Last question, Stu... the title of the book. Weren’t you concerned readers might think you smug and arrogant by writing about yourself?

A.  Yes! I told my editor calling the book Summers’ Love written by Stu Summers was too much, but she insisted that readers would catch the irony and find it humorous. She said that is part of the romantic comedy genre. But I guess it doesn’t work for every reader. Humor is hard to write. That’s why they say you need a sense of humor. Not everyone shares my “sense” and “none sense” but then, I’m not writing serious literature. I’m writing romantic comedy. We have more than enough serious and depressing issues to deal with at the clinic. I subscribe to the notion that if you can’t laugh at yourself, you can bet someone else will.
Not sure I answered all your questions the way you liked, but I appreciate you giving me the opportunity. In the end, I’m a flawed author who does his best and hopes readers will find a few laughs along the way. And, God knows, we need more laughter.


I'd like to write more but it is time to grab dinner and first I have to catch it. Sea ya!